top of page

Episode 25: When a Psychic is dead wrong

Writer: Kate
Kate
3 days ago
2 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Hi there, and welcome to another episode of Whispering Softly. Today, we explore the disappearance of Amanda Berry, who vanished without a trace after finishing a shift at a Burger King restaurant in Cleveland, Ohio, the day before her 17th birthday.


Days turned into months, into years, but Amanda's mother, Louwana Miller, refused to give up hope, eventually turning to one of America's most recognisable psychic mediums of the time, Sylvia Browne, for answers.


Appearing on national television, Browne confidently declared that Amanda was dead ... but she wasn't ...


Amanda Berry was alive, being held captive less than 10 miles from home. Nearly a decade later, she would rescue herself and expose one of the most infamous psychic predictions ever broadcast on television.


And here's where the story takes an unexpected turn ... because Amanda Berry was not the only woman held captive inside 2207 Seymour Avenue, Cleveland, Ohio.






19 News (8/05/2013). Missing: Timeline of Events.

ABC News (8/05/2013). Psychic Who Said Amanda Berry Was Dead Silent After Berry is Found Alive.

BBC News (7/05/2013). Profile: Amanda Berry, Georgina DeJesus and Michele Knight.

Campaigns & Elections (1/11/2003). Cleveland in Focus: A Profile from Census 2000.

Case Western Reserve University (12/09/2019). Encyclopedia of Cleveland History: Clark Fulton.

CBC News (7/05/2013). Amanda Berry's mother 'died of a broken heart' in 2006.

CBS News (9/05/2013). Celebrity psychic told Berry's mom her daughter was dead.

CBS News (9/05/2013). In note, Ariel Castro claimed he was sexually abused as a child.

Cleveland.com (1/05/2013). Amanda Berry's cell phone used a week after she went missing (republished story). Updated 12/10/2019.

Cleveland.com (2/08/2013). Ariel Castro's Seymour Avenue home reduced to rubble. Updated 12/01/2019.

CNN (youtube) (9/05/2013). Psychic was dead wrong about Amanda Berry.

CNN US (26/07/2013). Cleveland Kidnappings Fast Facts. Updated 24/04/2022.

Columbia Journalism Review (8/05/2013). The Plain Dealer columnist who knew Amanda Berry's mother.

FOX 8 (1/05/2013). 10 years later: Amanda Berry is 'facing her fears' and 'living her life'.

FOX 8 (8/05/2013). Sylvia Browne Responds to Wrong Berry Prediction.

KPBS (15/05/2013). When The Missing Return, Recovery Is Long, Too.

Moviedelic (5/07/2025). Cleveland Abduction Survivors: Where are they now?

Qualla. 2207 Seymour Avenue: Cleveland's House of Horrors.

Radar Online (14/05/2013). Rescued Cleveland Kidnap Victim Amanda Berry Visits Mother's Grave.

Skeptical Inquirer (Sept/Oct 2026). Still Psychic Defective: Examining Sylvia Browne's Predictions for Families of Crime Victims Years Later. Vol.5, No.5.

Society of Novus Spiritus: Gnostic Christians, Sylvia Browne, Founder.

Stop Sylvia Browne. Opal Jo Jennings: Reading on the Montel Williams Show.

The Guardian (8/05/2013). Three missing women found in Cleveland, Ohio - in pictures.

The Guardian (8/05/2013). Sylvia Browne: fans lash out at 'psychic' over false Ohio abduction prediction.

The Sydney Morning Herald (11/05/2026). Lost in plain sight.

True Crime News (9/11/2026): OK USA. The Ariel Castro Cleveland Kidnappings: inside the case of 3 women held captive for over a decade and his death in prison.

USA Today (10/05/2013). Psychic faces backlash over Amanda Berry prediction.

Who2 Biographies. Facts and Sylvia Browne.

Wikipedia. Ariel Castro kidnappings.

Wikipedia. Sylvia Browne.

Youtube (7/05/2013). Amanda Berry 911 Call - Cleveland Woman Freed.

Youtube (8/05/2013). Psychic Falsely Predicted Amanda Berry's Death.

Youtube (9/05/2013). Psychic was dead wrong about Amanda Berry.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page